Will I get a fair price selling off-market and as-is?

Selling off-market and as-is trades exposure to the full buyer pool for convenience, and that trade usually shows up in the price you get. Fewer buyers seeing the home means fewer offers to compare, which is what normally pushes a sale price up, while as-is pricing already assumes a discount for condition and repairs. Whether that tradeoff is fair depends on how much speed and privacy are worth to you personally. Joel Boss can show you what full market exposure would likely bring before you decide to go off-market.